Customer Reviews (1)

A Last-Day Must for Survival
Top notch scholarship from a warm heart that exposes Biblical translation errors resulting from anti-Jewish prejudice and reveals the relevance of today's Middle-East conflict to the fullfillment of Biblical prophecy and the kingdom of God coming on earth. An absolute must for serious students of the Bible or the Tanakh. ... Read more

Product Description
Here is a collection of substantive articles compiled to focus discussion on some weighty matters facing the Messianic Jewish movement. Reform rabbi, Dr. Dan Cohn-Sherbok, though not a Messianic Jew, is a friend of the movement. He believes that Messianic Judaism may be considered a branch of Judaism in this century. Professor of Judaism at the University of Wales, author of over 30 books, Rabbi Cohn-Sherbok guided the selection of topics addressed in this book. Here are some examples:

* Should Jewish believers in Messiah attend only Messianic Jewish congregations?

* Is intermarriage acceptable for Messianic Jews?

* Should liturgy have an essential role in congregational worship?

* How should outreach be accomplished?

Many of the best minds impacting this movement have contributed their thoughts to this book, creating a lively, informative, discussion. Each author, expressing his or her own view on a topic (often in direct opposition to another author), is a voice that can help this maturing movement confront the critical issues facing it. ... Read more

Customer Reviews (1)

Thoughtful
It is said that where there are two Jews, there are three opinions.

If that is true, then this book illustrates that Messianic Judaism is a true Judaism.Dan Cohn-Sherbok, not a Messianic Jew himself, has edited this anthology that explores issues that face the movement today.These individual essays include topics such as how to view scripture, the impact of intermarriage, gentile involvement in the movement, whether to offer conversion, whether women should receive smichah, and the relationship to Israel.

I'd say it's a must for those inside Messianic Judaism, and could be instructive for those on the outside who have at least visited Messianic congregations. ... Read more

Book Description
Presented from a distinctly Messianic Jewish perspective, the MessianicDaily Devotional is a collection of devotional writings unlike any you haveever read before.With selections ranging from gentle encouragement toinspiring exhortation, this unique and uplifting volume is an excellenttool for personal growth and discipleship in the Messiah Yeshua.JoinMessianic Jewish teacher and author Kevin Geoffrey on the journey towardbecoming effective disciples of the Master by developing alife-transforming, daily discipline of devotion. ... Read more

Customer Reviews (1)

Blessing to my husband
I bought this devotional for my husband this past Christmas, 2006.I loved what I saw when I searched inside the book online.He has absolutely loved it!I would recommend it to anyone looking for a wonderful devotional book.It has been so educational, and because of the research the author has done, is extremely insightful! ... Read more

Customer Reviews (2)

Discourse on Messianic Judiasm
The large majority of this book discusses the rise and fall of messianism through the medieval period and how it affects Judaism today. There are also other essays present that discuss the history of the Star of David symbolism and the mystical golems.

The author presents the case of how Sabbatianism and Hasidism influenced the messianic themes that are prevalent in today's Judiasm. Some of the more interesting readings cover the notion of Sabbatianism and its transformation to a sect that believes in a messiah that pointed the way to redemption through sin as a result of its heretical leadership.

Identifying some of the religious inadequacies of Sabbatianism and how they gave rise to Hasidism and the notion of a messianism that focuses on self and personal redemption, the author presents a plausible argument worthy of serious debate for years to come.

Messianism, Antinomianism, and Jewish Spirituality
Gershom Scholem, recognized as one of the foremost academic scholars of Jewish mysticism of the 20th century, presents here an excellent series of essays exploring the crises caused by fits of messianism in Judaism, especially the Sabbatian crisis.

The essays include:

Toward an Understanding of the Messianic Idea in Judaism- details the concept of the messiah (mosiach) in the Hebrew exoteric traditions throughout history.

The Messianic Idea in Kabbalism- explores the origins of kabbalistic messianism in Isaac Luria and how this paved the way for Sabbatai Zevi.

The Crisis of Tradition in Jewish Mysticism- discusses the antinomian tendencies of messianic movements (esp. in the Sabbatians and post-Sabbatians, such as the Frankists and the Donme) and how Jewish law is abridged by proclamations of a new law, which is further advanced in the next essay,

Redemption through Sin- a more thorough look at antinomianism in Judaism, and how it stems from the idea of Spiritual Torah vs. Written Torah.

Further essays explore the Donme movement in greater detail, takes a look at a rare Sabbatian will from a Sabbatian who lived in New York in the 1800's, further essays on Hasidism and it's retort to Messianism, as well as the mystical aspects of Devekut (Hasidic "Cleaving to God"), and further essays in Jewish scholarship and an essay on the birth of the Star of David as a Jewish symbol.

Highly recommended to all parties interested in more advanced scholarship in Kabbalah and Jewish Heresy. ... Read more

Book Description
The apostle Paul wrote that all believers--Jewish and Gentile--are to serve the Lord together as ''one new man.'' But a growing movement today seeks to keep that from happening. As Stan Telchin explains, proponents of Messianic Judaism are confusing both Jewish and Gentile followers of Jesus and dividing the church. Their insistence on following rabbinic form and their statements that Jewish believers need to be in Messianic synagogues in order to maintain their identities are unbiblical. Telchin discusses the growth of this movement, its unscriptural doctrines, and its ineffectiveness in Jewish evangelism. Those who have been swept up by the nostalgia and beauty of ''Jewishness'' or who have been hurt by division in the Body or who love Israel will find their hearts and minds freed by this firm but loving message. ... Read more

Customer Reviews (12)

Insightful, but anecdotal, needing deeper theological analysis
Telchin's book addresses the various distinctives and emphases of those communities of Jews who believe Jesus (Yeshua) to be the true Messiah, and the approaches which these communities take in relating to wider Judaism and to Christianity. His particular focus concerns "Messianic Synagogues" in the United States which have adopted post-New Testament rabbinic forms and practice which Telchin believes to be at variance with the Bible's (New Testament's) own teaching of the unity of Jesus' Jewish and Gentile followers, hence the title "Messianic Judaism is not Christianity". For non-Jewish readers the book is lacking in clarity as to what "rabbinic" practices actually are, although Telchin does point out that in many of Messianic fellowships the majority of adherents are in fact sympathetic Gentile believers. The book's analysis of the attitudes of Messianic Jews is rather anecdotal, and I would have liked to see a more thorough theological handling of Biblical passages of relevance. Telchin gives little indication that amongst Christians there are some different understandings of how Israel fits into God's purposes, and his treatment of Romans 11's "all Israel will be saved" gives no indication of interpretations other than his own. NT Wright's commentary of Romans has an in-depth presentation of an alternative approach. As with many books published in North America it largely ignores the situation in the rest of the world, although - in fairness - the United States is the principal location of Messianic congregations outside Israel. The book was helpful as an insight into some of the questions which are being addressed by Jewish believers in Jesus, and I would recommend it, but I found myself unsatisfied by the writing style and wanting a more thorough exploration of the Biblical values which Telchin, himself a Messianic Jew, holds. For myself, there is no divine covenant with Israel that does not include a saving relationship with Messiah Yeshua, Abraham's 'seed'. For Paul, the 'olive tree' that is the only true Israel of God is even now being formed of 1) Jews who continue in God's true covenant fulfilled and made 'new' through Jesus theMessiah and 2) Gentiles who have believed in Jesus, the Christ. By this process 'all Israel' will be saved. As Paul says, not all who are descended from Israel are 'Israel'.

Thesis on Stan Telchin" Book
Peace be to all. I finished reading Stan's book about a month ago. I have to say it was quite insightful. I've been studying the Jewish/Messianic Roots of the Christian Faith for almost 6 years now. I used to go to a Messianic Congregation, and the emphassis seems to be is trying to fit into the Jewish community, and not at times trying to follow the Messiah (Jesus). I think the leaders of the Messianic Movement need to read what Mr Telchin says. He has some words of wisdom from a man who knows alittle about Jewish evangelism. Only By lifting up Christ, and Him alone, can draw people to him. Whether it be Jew or Gentile. Its a good book, and I recommend everyone who is in the Messianic Movement to read and take some of Stan's words to heart. Shalom(Peace) be to all.

Dangerous and Unbiblical Book
This book has to be one of the stupidest books I have read in years.I could not believe how poorly researched it was and how poorly argued it is.Telchin is by no means a theologian of any sort.He is not even ordained and holds no leadership position in the Messianic Community.He seems to have written a book to take the opportunity to rant and rage against all things Christian and Messianic.His positions are so remarkably poorly argued that this reader could only conclude that Telchin took on subject matter way above his head.While Telchin writes under the cloak of "calling for unity", this book actually serves to divide one Christian from the other and does so contrary to the fundamentals of sound biblical doctrine.The book is so confusing and anti- Jewish and anti-biblical, that I wonder if Telchin had a more deeper and sinister reason for writing the book.The book leaves Telchin looking like he is anti-Semitic.
Those who read the book need to do so with great caution and Telchin's opinions as found in this book should be quickly discarded as the book is only going to serve to hurt the Christian community and hurt the Messianic community. I believe Telchin needs to issue a public retraction and apology for what he wrote.

A More Thorough Theological Critique Required
Having read Messianic Judaism by Dan Cohen-Sherbok and absorbed his evaluation of the place of the Messianic movement within Judaism, I eagerly awaited Mr. Telchin's work on the same subject from a Christian perspective.While I expected a thorough argument against Messianic Judaism's inclusion in the broader Christian tradition (based on the title), instead what was proposed was something theology of why Messianic Jews should not establish independent congregations.Though thorough in scope and interesting in logic, I will admit that I was disappointed by what seemed to be Telchin's need to trash Christianity.While it's important not to deny Christianity's anti-Judaic past, its also important to understand that past in the process of not denying it.He blatantly paints all the Church Fathers as anti-Semitic (which they were not) and the majority of Christian theology as being based on a need to "put down" the Jews (it was not).Still, Telchin is to be praised for his thorough elucidation of the problems endemic to the Messianic congregational movement, particularly as they relate to Messianic relations (or lack thereof) with other Christian communities.

Helpful, irenic critique
 His conclusion: "Messianic Judaism and Messianic synagogues have no biblical, theological, historical or pragmatic justification." (p. 25).Telchin knows that the modern Messianic movement is more than just Christianity contextualized for ethnic Jews.Their desire to be a '4th branch of Judaism" is insulting to both Judaism and Christianity.
 
Telchin is no theologian, but he has a very interesting story to tell.

His requisite chapter on antiSemiticism includes some heart-breaking sound bites from John Chrysostom. ... Read more

Book Description
Agues for the irrevocable election of Israel and a bold, bridging role--between Judaism and the Gentile church--for the Messianic Jewish movement. ... Read more

Customer Reviews (2)

Post-Missionary Messianic Judaism a Challenge for Jews and Christians alike
Dr. Mark Kinzer has written a groundbreaking book that cannot be simply overlooked. His conclusions of Messianic Judaism, and its reprocussions on Christianity and Judaism are innovative and based on solid scholarship.Many well known scholars have already begun to take notice.

A maturing Messianic Judaism
Dr. Mark Kinzer's well-thought, carefully argued presentation of what he has coined "Postmissionary Messianic Judaism,"is a must read for all theologians and pastors.Relying not only on his own biblical scholarship and exegesis, but on that of many other scholars as well, Dr. Kinzer presents the reader with a form of Messianic Judaism that retains faithfulness both to the traditions and teachings of Judaism, and to New Testament theology.
The author argues that a careful study of the New Testament reveals that both Jesus (Yeshua) and his disciples not only followed the commandments (mitzvot) of the Torah (Old Testament), but taught that all Jewish followers of Jesus were obligated to observe the commandments, also. The early community of Jewish believers in Jerusalem made it clear that Gentile followers of Yeshua were not required to observe the commandments that had beenespecially reserved for the Jewish people. Dr. Kinzer further explains that by the beginning of the 2nd century CE, the largely Gentile Christian church began to teach that it had superseded Israel as the new people of God, and that observing the Torah was contrary to New Testament teaching -- even for Jewish believers in Yeshua.
Dr. Kinzer argues that a proper understanding of New Testament teaching would correctly view the Jewish people as still being the people of God, and that through Yeshua the covenants first made with Israel have been expanded to include Gentile Christians.But in order to understand their proper relationship to the Jewish people, there must also exist a bridge between the two, which is made up of Jewish believers in Yeshua who retain their ties to the rest of the Jewish community by remaining Torah observant, and tied to the Gentile Christian community by their faith in Yeshua.
Dr. Kinzer's book provides a way for both a fresh and timely way of bridging the schism that remains between Judaism and Christianity. ... Read more

Book Description
This compendium of all the prophecies in Scripture concerns the promised Messiah. Dr. Lockyer's discussion is divided into two sections, "Specific Messianic Prophecies" and "Symbolic Messianic Prophecies." ... Read more

Customer Reviews (3)

All the Messianic Prophecies of the Bible
I am so thankful to have this put into one book.It makes is so easy to study and very informative.Keep up the great work.

Focused on Jesus Christ:The Theme of the Bible
Jesus Christ is the only Redeemer of sinful man.Jesus Christ is the only full revelation of God, as revealed in the Bible.History is utterly dependent on Jesus Christ, who He is and what He is doing.So this book will take you a long way in focusing your interpretation of scripture on what, or Who, scripture is about.Here is a book that is excellent for one wanting to start studying more in depth the MANY attributes and works of Jesus Christ and how all of history revolves around His sovereignty.Mr. Lockyer does a great job and will get you started, expanding your mind beyond the "milk" theology in which so many Christians remain.But be careful.He bought into the very young doctrines of premillennialism and dispensationalism, so you will find his doctrinal explanations as related to the return of Jesus Christ to be "newspaper" theology rather than biblical theology.

A great critique of all the specific and symbolic prophecies
This the best book on the Messianic prophecies that were attributed to Christ!It goes into unprecedented depth in the symbolic messianic prophecies which not too many authors chose to go into.This is anexcellent book from an acclaimed author who was beyond 80 years of age whenhe wrote the book. ... Read more

Book Description
Yeshua and his Jewish followers began a new movement--Messianic Judaism--2000 years ago. In the twentieth century, it was reborn, and now, at the beginning of the twenty-first century, it is maturing. The Enduring Paradox is a collection of essays from some of the top contributors to the theology of this vital movement of God. ... Read more

Customer Reviews (2)

Great and hepful in theology and hsitory, but some confusion on practical issues
The Enduring Paradox is a survey of Messianic Judaism, covering three main areas: Theology, Israel, and Practical Jewish issues.Overall it is a very concise treatment of a lot of important topics in the Messianic movement.

The theology section is fantastic.For example, Walter Kaiser (who has written extensively on the Tanach, or "Old Testament") contributed a fantastic survey of the Messianic prophecies.This is required reading for all who take the Bible seriously, weather Christian, Jew, or Messianic Jew.John Fisher's section on the covenant aspect of the Scripture is also very informative, especially for those new to Messianic Jewish thinking.Schiffman does as nice job discussing the nature of God, Father Son and Spirit, into a Jewish context (but is very brief ... a shame!).

The section about Israel is also very good.Elliot Klayman's brief survey of the Israeli law of return is very relevant.David Stern, who has also written extensively on Messianic Issues, also contributes two very nice articles on how the land and in particular Jerusalem is vital to the promised of God.These essays, and in particular the one on Jerusalem, should be required reading for Christians who don not understand "the fascination" with the land of Israel.

The practical issues section was also very helpful, but there were a few warning flags.I found the essay by Patrice Fisher on the assimilation of Jews in America to be very helpful, especially in terms of outreach to the Jewish community.But another article by Patrice is very weak, by saying some Gentiles "may wish to formally convert to Judaism."This is not only a clear violation of Scripture, but will further enrage the Jewish community against Messianic Jews with what may turn out to be deception.Patrice also walks a fine line saying that Gentiles can be members of Messianic fellowships provided they "maintain Torah practices like biblical God-fearing gentiles."Not enough discussion is really devoted to what that means because for example, not all Messianic congregations keep kosher, and some who claim to really don't.In addition, John Fischer has a good essay about rabbinic tradition.I loved his article in the sense he explains that not everything the Rabbis said was bad, a point many Christians fail to realize.But Fischer dramatically oversimplifies the problem, because the Talmud for example has many things in it that Yeshua (Jesus) condemned and Fischer magically omits these issues from his essay.The Talmud is what it is; it is like a commentary and in commentary some are bad and some are good.

Overall this is a very insightful book that Messianic Jews will find helpful in their walk with God.There is a lot of Scripture in it and as such it might be useful for Christians to understand the Messianic position, for example to deal with issues of "Replacement Theology."When appropriate, the authors point out mistakes in Christianity without mocking their Christian brothers; I found this tone very mature and loving.I would give it 5 stars but those odd comments in Patrice Fisher's essays make me consider it a 4.5 stars or so book.

Stimulating Insights About Messianic Judaism &Jewish Roots
"The Enduring Paradox" is a collection of scholary but clear essays addressing theological and practical questions of interest to Messianic Jews and students of Scripture in general.
The essayists include some big guns in the evangelical world, including Walter Kaiser and Louis Goldberg, as well asa number of Messianic Judaism's scholars.The editor, John Fisher (and his wife Patrice) contributes the greatest number of essays.

The book is divided into three sections, (1) Messianic Jewish Theology, (2) Messianic Jews and Israel, and (3) Practical Issues for Messianic Jews and Non-Jews.

There is much to be praised in this book.Patrice Fisher's chart on page 178, distinguishing between native-born Jews, Godfearers, Foreigners, and Pagans is simple but superb in its clarity. Lawrence Rich's chapter on "Jewish Practice and Identity in the Book of Acts" is worth the purchase price of the book.

On the negative side, John Fisher's chapter about, "Covenant, Fulfillment, and Judaism in Hebrews" seems a bit of a stretch.
It is important to interpret Scripture without a pre-existing agenda.

This book is not for everyone, but it is written clearly and it is not lenghty. Most dedicated laymen can grasp it.Good fodder for thought, especially for those who value the Jewish roots of Christianity, are serious about Bible interpretation, or participate in the Messianic Jewish movement. ... Read more

Book Description
Messianic Judaism is a modern movement with an ancient past. Its resurgence in these last days may hold the key to world redemption. A bridge between Jews and Christians, today's Messianic Jewish movement is being used by God to reach his chosen people. Dr. Michael Schiffman, a Messianic Jew, gives us a comprehensive understanding of Messianic Judaism. In Return of the Remnant he: documents Messianic Jewish history from the first century to today; explains where Messianic Judaism fits theologically and culturally; examines difficult issues concerning both Jews and non-Jews--the Law, the tri-unity of God, etc. He reports his research on modern Messianic congregations and shows how Messianic Judaism relates to both synagogue and church. Paperback, 180 pages. ... Read more

Customer Reviews (2)

DX: Purely ponderous drudgery:-(
The author frequently rhetorically contradicts himself.Content information is shallow historically and theologically, and at times is in error. The 38 pages of statistics at the end of the book are wanting and appear to be just filler to increase the size of the book.Not very scholarly.

For more concise, un-biased, information on the history, theology and sociology of Messianic Judaism I highly recommend Carol Harris-Shapiro's book, "Messianic Judaism, A Rabbi's Journey through Religious Change in America."Rabbi Harris-Shapiro gives a more detailed and concise overview.

Hard questions answered
Micheal Shiftman gives a very readable introduction to messianic Judism. He addresses areas of conflict between rabinical Judism and traditional christian thought by restoring the first century meaning behind Yeshuah'sand Rav. Shaul's(Paul's), teaching. I reccomend it as a book for those whowant to know how Messianic Judism has developed,and its historicalbackground. ... Read more

Book Description
Get ready to cross the Jordan and enter the Land of Promise! As you listen to Moshe's words, learn from past wanderings and prepare to claim your inheritance. You can walk the path of blessing with the next generation and serve as priests. Learn to hold God in awe, keep His commands, hear His voice, and cleave to Him. In return, God promises long life in the Land, from generation to generation, to the end of time. ... Read more

Customer Reviews (8)

The faulty conclusion abrogates the value of the research
No matter how detailed and informative the research done here by Cohn- Sherbok the conclusion he draws is in total contradiction with Judaism.
It is true that we live in an age in which every possible combination of thing imaginable is considered valid and authentic reality.
But Judaism survived for generations in spite of persistent efforts of those who believed Jesus the Messiah , to convert or destroy them.
This historical record, including the record of Jewish martydom through the Ages in resisting forced conversion is made a mockery of by those who claim that they are both Jewish and Christian in religion.
As I understand it those people who are born Jews and convert to Christianity are not simply free individuals exercising their personal prerogative- they are traitors to their own people's history, and faith.
To be Jewish historically is to deny that one is a Christian.
Cohn- Sherbok in advocating otherwise does the Jewish people who are in deep demographic crisis a real disservice. This when there are over two billion Christians in the world( By far the world's largest faith) and the Jews have not even come close to coming back to the numbers they had at the eve of the Second World War.

For Mixed Audiences
...
There are several good points to this book.First, it has an excellent (if obtusely written) historical overview of Hebrew Christianity and Messianic Judaism.Second, it does go into great detail as to the why and what of Messianic Jewish belief, as well as ritual practice and observance.He also has a chapter specifically concerning dissenting opinions about Messianic Judaism.
Never the less, there are a few very serious problems.First, it is unclear who his intended audience is from his discussion of Messianic Liturgical practices.Is he writing for Christians or for Jews?Obviously, a Jew with any common knowledge of how a service was structured would find the information he presents in several places rudimentary.I am lead to believe that he cannot possibly be expecting to find Jewish audiences in this book because some Jews that I know (some, not all, and only the ones I know, not everybody) would rather spit on anything "Messianic" that look at it, let alone read or understand it, so he can't be writing for Jews, but for Christians.If that's the case, then he needs to make a better argument as to why Christians should accept Jewish expressions of Christianity, not why Messianics should be included in the Jewish community.He continually confuses the audience as to whom he is speaking.Secondly, his defense of Messianic Judaism as a legitimate expression of Jewishness is, at best, misplaced.It comes after his chapter on dissenting opinions from within the Jewish community.He offers no real defense of MJ except to say that they should be accepted because there are other non-Orthodox branches that aren't excluded and the plurality of Jews in the West can't put themselves into a definable box anyway.This is, of course, a silly argument.Of course MJ can be excluded form being a legitimate expression of Judaism because it, unlike any other branch, believes Jesus is the Messiah.Non-belief in the Messiahship of Jesus is a prerequisite to entrance into the Jewish community.By itself, this argument does not stand.It would have been better to cite some examples of historic opinions from Judaism that support might Trinitarian notions as well as historic and modern groups that hold Messianic convictions about an individual (read: the Lubavitcher Chassidim).That would have made his argument for inclusion much stronger.Finally, he does not allow Messianic Jews to answer their accusers, particularly the ones that "converted" back from Christianity/Messianic Judaism.I noticed that not one of those individuals remained Christians.Instead, always they went back to Judaism, and always in a pretty neat formula ("I wasn't very Jewish, I got mixed up in this horrible group (read: cult) but some kind Jewish soul showed me the light.Now I'm a real Jew, more Jewish than I was when I was one of 'those' people, and everything is just super because everything they ever told me was a lie."It sounds more than a little contrived, and it's defiantly propaganda.)Each of these is a serious omission that should have been included to lend credibility to his arguments.

Nevertheless, Rabbi Cohn-Sherbok should be commended for this book.It is bold, displays a high level of commitment to a level of objectivity.This is a touchy subject for all sides of the debate, and while it's not apparent which side of the debate the Rabbi is on, he is at least willing to look with fairness towards MJ, especially since it is often ignored/discredited without even cursory consideration of the shell game of an argument being used against them.If there is ever to be reasonable dialogue, then such attacks must cease and desist.Unfortunately, however, I don't think that any side is willing to put aside its agenda and reason together, but perhaps this book will at least change some of that.

Good information, but his conclusions are faulty
This book is filled with a lot of good information, but the problem I have is after carefully showing how messianic Judaism is really the brainchild and outgrowth of evangelical Christian attempts to convert Jews he throws up his hands and says that we should accept it as if it were a natural development of Judaism. It is not surprising that his views are soundly repudiated from all the branches in Judaism, including the Reform which he claims to be a member of.

From the standpoint of a Messianic Jew....
My dear friend, "a reader from New England" is wrong. I seriously doubt he or she even read the book. Dan Cohen-Sherbok's opus isone done of courage and tenacity and of not being afraid to see things thatone necessarily doesn't want to see. When the "reader from NewEngland" piously states, "Jesus DID say that he came to releasehis followers from the 'curse of the law', did he not?", he or she notonly casts a glaring spotlight on their own ignorance, but the foundationalproblem within mainline Christianity. The apostle Paul, in his letter toGalatians, stated in Galatians 3:13, "Christ hath redeemed us from thecurse of the law, being made a curse for us." He was referring to (ifone takes the time to read the entire context and not just the portion thatsupports his or her own theological agenda) the fact that through Christ,no one has to try to "work" their way to heaven anymore. Indeed,Yeshua HaMashiach stated, "Think not that I am come to destroy thelaw, or the prophets: I am not come to destroy, but to fulfil."(Matthew 5:17) Why would He fulfill something that would be cursed? DanCohen-Sherbok's book is one that everyone, Jew and Gentile alike, andESPECIALLY Christians should read and study and take to heart. I highlyrecommend it. Messianic Judaism is a much of part of Judaism as isOrthodox, Conservative, or Reform. Dan Cohen-Sherbok obviously agrees.

messianic judaism
This is a profoundly interesting book.There is no doubt the Jewish community detests Messianic Judaism and puts it about on a par withholocaust denial.Sadly, this is a knee-jerk reaction.Rabbi Cohn-Sherbokwho is himself a Reform Jew and, from the evidence of his other booksshares none of the beliefs of the Messianic community, has done anexcellent job in presenting the history, beliefs and practices of the groupobjectively.It is an important piece of research and he has talked tocritics of the movement as well as adherents.From his account, it is hardto imagine why any rational person would want to join the movement, butnonetheless it does appeart to be growing.If this is the case then it isimportant that the mainstream Jewish community voices its objections fromthe basis of secure knowledge.This book is an informed and fascinatingpiece of work and as such should be part of the library of every yeshiva,rabbinical college and synagogue.If the mainstream community were onlysecure enough to learn from fringe movements and make some attempt tounderstand their appeal to the more vulnerable members of our community,our synagogues might be fuller and our young people less turned off. Instead, the community prefers blanket condemnation and unreasoned abuse. No wonder the educated youth of today are disaffected.Rabbi Cohn-Sherbokis to be congratulated on his single-handed attempt to redress the balance;it is splendid to find someone in this day and age who takes Milton'sdefence of a free press seriously; as the great seventeenth century poetput it in his 'Areopagitica', 'Whoever knew Truth put to the worst in freeand open discussion.' The Jewish community has nothing to fear from theMessianics; we simply need to be more confident in what we ourselves haveto offer. ... Read more

Book Description

The messianic idea that a redeemer sent by God will come to end the suffering of a persecuted people and inaugurate a new age of justice and peace has been one of the most powerful and influential concepts given by the Jewish people to western civilization. This book represents a sample of the most penetrating and provocative scholarly interpretations of Jewish messianic movement from various perspectives- historical, sociological, psychological, and religious.

Book Description
Most Christians imagine that the poison of anti-Judaism hasbeen largely eliminated. In contrast, Milavec reveals how this poison hasgone underground. At each step of the way, Milavec's sure hand buildsbridges of mutual understanding that enable both Christians and Jews tocross the chasm of distrust and distortion that has infected both churchand synagogue over the centuries. Milavec securely brings his readers tothat place where Rabbinic Judaism and Christianity can again be admired assister religions intimately united to one other in God's drama ofsalvation. ... Read more

Customer Reviews (1)

Hard Questions
The author is Catholic, so his frame of reference involves statements issues by Catholic leaders. His position is squarely based on his initial experience with one Jewish man, Mr Martin and clearly builds from that into several tough questions about salvation from a Christian perspective.He cautions repeatedly that his topics and conclusions will make Christians uncomfortable. He deals directly with the identity of Messiah and Jewish relationships to God. Be ready since his conclusions are radical but necessary. His approach is refreshing since he's not hoping to stimulate Jewish conversion by acting respectful of their beliefs and practices (unlike the other book with the same name by another author).

Some other books that fill in more substance to this include: Jacob Neusner' Performing Israel's Faith, John Gager's Reinventing Paul and Amy Levine's The Misunderstood Jew. There's alot available on the historical Jesus, the "New" Paul and Jewish Christian relations through history. I have found books by Abraham Heschel to be excellent for some in depth Orthodox Jewish thought, especially his Heavenly Torah.

If you think Jews are lost, misguided and/or going to Hell for not accepting Jesus then read this book. ... Read more

Customer Reviews (1)

Judaism revealed in light of the messiah. Good Stuff.
This book is full of good historical and theological information written in a way that the basic layman can understand. Great for those curious about Judaism and the Messiah. Good information about Judaism and how its traditions affect our relationship with God and our daily life. Great resources with lots of good references. ... Read more

Book Description
More than just a Messianic Bible study, "Being a Disciple of Messiah" is a powerful, life-transforming discipleship experience.Whether you are new to small group leadership or are an experienced discipler, your students will be challenged and invigorated as they dive into The Messianic Life Discipleship Series.This Leader's Guide contains: "Prepare Your Heart" questions designed specifically for leader preparation; answers, references and insights for effective facilitation of the material; "For the Next Generation..." special children's questions for each session; "Our Take-Away," offering our perspective on the sessions' main points; and suggestions and additional helps for leading a dynamic small group/discipleship ministry.Your students, small groups and community will never be the same, as they allow the Lord to do a unique and lasting work that will lead them into the fullness of the Messianic life.The Messianic Life Discipleship Series is intended for small group, one-on-one discipleship, or individual use. Presented from a Messianic Jewish perspective, each volume is a unique tool designed to help both new and seasoned believers alike to live a mature, fruitful life for Messiah. Based firmly in Scripture, these resources encourage transparent interaction for the purpose of changing lives. The Messianic Life Discipleship Series will continually challenge and inspire you to become more like the Master every day. Join Messianic Jewish teacher and author Kevin Geoffrey as he exhorts Messianic believers to live a life completely "sold-out" to Yeshua! ... Read more

Product Description
A captivating true story. ... Read more

Customer Reviews (1)

A Jewish girl finds her Messiah!
In Israel, a native Jew is called a Sabra (a prickly pear).Hence the book's title.Yaffa's story is a very real, heart-grabbing account of what she endured and encountered on her adventure to accepting Jesus Christ as The Messiah.Her honesty and descriptions give you a real sense of being with her on the journey.I found myself experiencing tears of sorrow and tears of great joy...

This biography impressed me and convicted me.I discovered that for a Jew to become a Messianic Jew is not a small step as some gentile Christians might have thought (including me). Yaffa's story made me understand that as gentile Christians, we need to learn (1) to show respect and love to the Jews, including their traditions; (2) to connect with them based on the truths of the Old Testament which point the way to Jesus Christ and will enrich our Christian faith; (3) to lead them to their Jewish Messiah who is also our Jewish Messiah - not to make them gentile Christians.Read it for yourself and see if you agree with me. ... Read more

Book Description
This illustrated nonfiction book provides an overview of world ideologies, the convoluted history of the Church and Christianity's inherent Jewishness. "One of the most comprehensive works on the subject of Jewish roots is titled 'Return to the Fountainhead of the Faith,' by Shelley Gauld. Her book is very readable and is a treasure-chest filled with practical knowledge and insight. This is not dry academicism. It is a piece of artwork that touches head and heart." Rev. Frank Lenihan, Montana USA *** The first edition of this book (c 2003) was nominated for the 2004 Koret Foundation Jewish Book Awards. See also this author's memoir; "Much Bigger than Grownups: Chronicles of a Native South African." ... Read more

Customer Reviews (1)

Reviews from Writer's Digest and Readers
Writer's Digest 15th Annual International Self-Published Book Awards.
Judge's Commentary: Some really deep information on religious traditions! You have taken on a monumental subject. An extremely useful reference book. I particularly enjoyed the many definitions of Jewish traditions and words.

Memorable Comments

"I have been fascinated by your scholarly writing of Return to the Fountainhead of the Faith. Whatever I have read in your work that pertains to the Jewish faith has been detailed and accurate--and written in a spirit of love and reverence, which I much appreciate." (Robin. Margate, South Africa. A Jewish high school teacher and mother of an ultra-orthodox Rabbi.)

"One of the most comprehensive and easy to read books on the subject of Jewish roots is titled Return to the Fountainhead of the Faith, by Shelley Gauld. Her book is very readable and, at almost 300 pages, is a treasure-chest filled with very practical knowledge and insight. The book is not dry academicism. It is a piece of artwork that touches head and heart." (Rev. Frank Lenihan, Montana USA)

"Roma [representative of International Christian Embassy Jerusalem] says `Return' covers what she considers to be the most important aspects of Christianity's Jewish roots. She is happy to have confirmation regarding what she has been teaching and sharing for so long--from someone she doesn't know, living in America!" (Marion. Westville, South Africa.)

"The time is right for such a work! What strikes me is that the book is essentially advanced material for mature Christians but, at the same time, has the inherent potential to function as the first step to salvation. What a combination!" (Renee. Winterton, South Africa)

"Irrespective of one's spiritual convictions, this book makes compelling reading. A must-read for the roaming, inquisitive mind." (Jeanette Gilks. Assagay, South Africa)

"What a wonderful resource!" (Joyce. Golden, Colorado USA. Joyce bought fourteen copies and sent them to all the clergy in her family.)

"It seems that there may be more of a connection between Jews and Gentiles than I had previously supposed . . ." (Gary. Dallas, Texas USA)

... Read more

Product Description
Here are words of encouragement that offer insight into the Jewish Scriptures--both Old and New Testaments.

Twenty-two prominent Messianic contributors provide practical ways to apply biblical truth. These devotions--

* explore the Jewish roots of the New Testament
* explain Hebrew words and phrases
* are filled with anecdotes from Jewish life and literature

Jump-start your day with this unique resource. Keyed to the Hebrew calendar, this unique devotional begins with the month of Tishri.

Extensive appendices include information on the Hebrew calendar, biblical and traditional feast days, and traditional weekly readings from the Torah (Pentateuch), Haftarah (Prophets), and the Brit Chadashah (New Testament). ... Read more

Customer Reviews (4)

~Edifying and Insightful~
This is a must for anyone who wishes to add to thier collection of devotionals and commentaries. I own and read several devotionals including Spurgeons Morning/Evening,My Utmost for His Highest and a Calvary Chapel Pastors Devotional, this Messianic perspective on the Scriptures add some salt to my collection. The Messianic perspective has much to add and is a blessing to the reader in building him up in his faith through edification, conviction, humor and praise of our King Yeshua. Don't miss this one !

The Voice of the Lord Messianic Jewish Daily Devotional
This is a must for those seeking understanding for their daily walk with Yeshua. It is a refreshing light with great insight and a good way to share the Word and the Good News. It is the way that our day starts and the words carry us through with a longing for what is to come the next day. It is a must for the Messianic believer.

A little gem of a devotional!
This is a little gem of a devotional!Twenty-two contributors (equivalent to the number of letters in the Hebrew alphabet), representing a "broad spectrum of the Messianic Jewish community," have shared their insight into various Scripture passages, giving the book a decidedly unique perspective compared to other devotionals I have looked it.Although each day's commentary is only a page long, each devotion is packed with punch, often giving Jewish background or customs to each reading.Key Hebrew words are sprinkled throughout with the English translation included in parentheses.The Jewish calendar is followed, however Western dates, six years worth (beginning in 1998), are included so the reader can easily follow throughout the year.Each page has a side-column that shows the stage of the moon on that particular date.Also listed are any important biblical events that have occurred, as well as the traditional Jewish holy days and observances that are celebrated. A small section in the column is left for personal writing or a "prayer focus."There are three appendices that cover the biblical festivals, the traditional Jewish observances, and a synagogue reading cycle.

As a personal note, I would like to add that the reading cycle is especially insightful each week, and I realized that even more after reading the author's comments when introducing the concept to the reader:

"Do you intercede for Israel's salvation? If not, the synagogue reading cycle, like an alarm clock, can wake you up to this most important responsibility.It will remind you of the seasons when many of our people around the world are turning their hearts to God in prayer, repentance and meditation on his Word.These are the ideal times to pray for our people — marvelous windows of opportunity to send our prayers heavenward.Let us remember that the best time to pray for Israel is when Israel is praying."

— Ronni

An inspriational, educational, and practical book.
This book is really my first taste of a Messianic devotional and I really enjoy the flavor, although I concede that it may be an acquired taste.Like most devotionals, it has short daily readings that help you to thinkabout Godly things and about how you are doing in your spiritual walk withthe Lord.What sets it apart is that all 22 authors are leaders in theMessianic movement.

The authors consistently use the Hebrew (or Yiddish,etc.) terms for many words that we have translated into English, therebylosing some of the meaning and "feel" of the chosen word from theoriginal language.But not to worry, they are usually translated for youright there so that you still understand everything that is being said. This constant saturation with the more meaningful proper terms helps you tofeel closer to the Jewish people and understand their thought processbetter.Also, interjected into some of the readings are historicalaccounts or other information that would only normally be known by personswith a Jewish background, which further helps us to acquire an educatedknowledge of their culture.

Other features include the Hebrew calendardate in bold display at the top corners of each page and the correspondingGregorian calendar dates below, up through the year 2004.The names of thewriters do not appear on each page which really helps you to concentrate onthe teaching and to give glory to God and not to the man who wrote theparticular piece.However, the individual authors' initials do appear insmall fine print at the bottom so that you can look them up in the index atthe front of the book.The index, by the way, gives a brief profile ofeach author, which will also help you to get a feel for who is who in theMessianic movement around the world.There is a small sidebar for listingprayer requests and there is also a thought of the day (Today I will...) tomake the teaching practical at the bottom of each page.An inspirational,educational, practical, and handsome book. ... Read more

Book Description
This two-color, 36-page illustrated book guides you through the traditional Passover seder dinner, step-by-step.

Not only does the Passover observance remind us of the Israelites' rescue from Egyptian bondage, but, we also remember the Messiah's last supper, a Passover seder. The theme of redemption is seen throughout the evening.

Our Haggadah (a Hebrew word, which means "the telling") is unique. It focuses on Yeshua (Jesus) the Messiah and his teaching, especially on his last night in the upper room.

Includes words and sheet music of the songs mentioned in the book and sung on Passover.

Uses the popular Complete Jewish Bible where the Scriptures are quoted. ... Read more

Customer Reviews (11)

The meaning of Passover
is about the Jews' emergence from slavery to Mt. Sinai with
G-d's help, where they received the law. Anything else can't be called a "Haggadah".

I hate to offend anyone but
I hate to offend anyone but I find the idea of a 'Messianic' Haggadah offensive.
Passover is a Jewish not a Christian holiday.
I think it would be far more considerate of those who call themselves ' Messianic' to simply be Christians and not try to co-opt Jewish traditional practices, and use them in a way never intended.

messianic is not jewish
please be aware that the one thing jews across the entire spectrum from orthodox to reform agree upon is that it is not possible to be jewish and believe in jesus at the same time.while a person who believes in jesus and lives according to jewish teachings may well be utterly good and decent, s/he is following a tradition that is not accepted within the faith tradition known as judaism.furthermore, many messianics in my experience conceal this piece of information.i thus wish to note:caveat emptor!

This book is a lie
It is not a haggadah.Jesus or "Yeshua" did not exist at the time of the Exodus, is not the Moshiach, and is not a deity.This is a book for Christians, not Jews.

Messianic seder
This is an excellent edition of the messianic seder service. It will give non-Jews an insight to the last supper of Jesus. One criticism is that there does not appear the blesing for "al achilat matzah," which, I think, is pretty important ... Read more